Tried and Tested Baby Bottles That Work

By Jordan Malik, Family Gear Reviewer | Product Picks Column | Childcare Standards Council

Choosing the right baby bottle might seem straightforward, but if you’ve ever been overwhelmed by endless options, you’re not alone. Whether you’re bottle feeding expressed milk, formula, or introducing a bottle alongside breastfeeding, picking a bottle that your baby actually accepts and that works well for you is key.

From preventing colic to easy cleaning, the best baby bottles balance practical features with design that suits your little one’s needs. After testing many bottles on real babies (and with feedback from parents), here’s an honest, no nonsense look at tried and tested baby bottles that really work in 2025.

Contact us to report infringement.

Why the Right Bottle Matters

Babies can be surprisingly picky when it comes to feeding. A bottle that’s too hard to suck from, leaks, or causes discomfort can lead to feeding struggles. Plus, the wrong bottle can contribute to excessive wind or colic.

What to look for in a baby bottle? Key factors include:

• Nipple shape and flow: Mimics breastfeeding and controls milk flow to reduce choking or gulping

• Anti colic features: Valves or vents to reduce swallowed air

• Material: BPA free plastic, glass, or silicone, depending on preference

• Ease of cleaning: Fewer parts and wide necks are a plus

• Durability and safety: Strong, heat resistant materials that withstand sterilising

  
  

1. Philips Avent Natural Baby Bottle

Best Overall

Avent has been a trusted brand for years, and the Natural bottle continues to deliver. Its wide nipple shape mimics the breast, helping babies transition between breast and bottle feeding. The anti colic valve sits at the base, reducing discomfort caused by trapped air.

Why it works:

• Soft, flexible nipple with natural feel

• Easy to clean with a wide neck

• Compatible with Avent’s breast pumps and accessories

  
  

Points to note:

• Can be a little bulky in the bag

• Nipple replacement recommended every 2 months

  
  

Price: Around £6 to £7 per bottle

2. Tommee Tippee Closer to Nature

Tommee Tippee’s Closer to Nature bottles are a favourite for parents wanting a familiar breastfeeding experience. The nipple has a breast like shape and a slow flow option that works well for newborns.

Why it works:

• Soft silicone nipple with natural flex

• Anti colic valve in the teat reduces wind

• Compact and lightweight

  
  

Points to note:

• Some babies prefer the Avent nipple shape more

• May require frequent cleaning of the valve

  
  

Price: Around £5 to £6 per bottle

3. Dr Brown’s Options+ Anti Colic Bottle

Best for Colic Relief

Dr Brown’s bottles have a unique internal vent system designed specifically to reduce colic, gas, and spit up. This system helps maintain essential vitamins in formula by limiting exposure to air.

Why it works:

• Effective vent system to reduce discomfort

• Compatible with breast pumps

• Options for slow to fast flow nipples

  
  

Points to note:

• More parts to clean than other bottles

• Bulkier design

  
  

Price: Around £8 to £9 per bottle

4. Comotomo Baby Bottle

Best for Breastfeeding Transition

Comotomo bottles are made from soft silicone, which many babies find closest to the feel of a real breast. Their wide neck and nipple shape help reduce nipple confusion.

Why it works:

• Soft, squeezable silicone bottle

• Wide neck for easy cleaning

• Designed to reduce colic and spit up

  
  

Points to note:

• Higher price point

• Silicone bottle may feel unusual to some parents

  
  

Price: Around £15 per bottle

5. MAM Anti Colic Bottle

Best for Easy Cleaning

MAM’s bottles are popular thanks to their self sterilising feature, which is perfect for busy parents on the go. Their vented base helps reduce colic, and the nipple is designed to feel natural.

Why it works:

• Sterilises in the microwave in 3 minutes

• Easy to clean with wide neck

• Anti colic vent system

  
  

Points to note:

• Nipple can wear out quickly

• Some parents find the bottle shape bulky

  
  

Price: Around £7 to £8 per bottle

Tips for Choosing and Using Baby Bottles

Try different nipples and flows

Babies have their own preferences. Experiment with slow, medium, and fast flow nipples to find what suits your baby’s age and feeding style.

Clean bottles thoroughly

Make sure to wash all parts well and sterilise regularly, especially in the first months. Bottles with fewer parts are usually easier to manage.

Consider your lifestyle

If you’re often out and about, look for lightweight bottles that fit easily in bags and are durable.

Watch for signs of feeding issues

If your baby is gulping, choking, or fussing, the bottle or nipple flow might not be right.

Final Thoughts

There’s no one size fits all when it comes to baby bottles, but the ones listed above have stood the test of time in 2025. The best baby bottles are those that suit your baby’s feeding habits, reduce discomfort, and make your life easier.

Remember, patience is key. Sometimes it takes a little trial and error before both you and your baby find the perfect fit. Whichever bottle you choose, focus on safe materials, easy cleaning, and comfort for your little one.